
The tragic death of Jason Arday has brought up difficult and painful issues for many people this week. I can’t begin to address all the issues surrounding his death with any particular expertise, so I’ll leave them well alone. But his death has got my thinking about something else.
I don’t know what was going on inside Jason’s mind, and I don’t want to speculate about why he took his own life. What I find myself wondering about, though, is what happens when our professional identity becomes so entwined with our sense of who we are that losing one can feel like losing the other.
It seems to me that we can unconsciously absorb the idea that if our reputation and career prospects are ruined, then somehow, we are ruined too. That if we have failed badly enough, or been disgraced enough, there is no meaningful future left for us.
But is that really true?
There are plenty of disgraced politicians, for example, who are alive and kicking. Some are eventually rehabilitated back into society, and even back into politics. They may never regain the level of respect they once enjoyed, and they may have to live with the consequences of what happened. But their lives go on.
In traditional Samurai culture the rules were spelled out for you: bring shame on your clan or family (including by being taken prisoner) and it was expected that you would commit seppuku.
Fortunately, most of us live in a culture where there are other options. And I know this because I have experienced something of my own version of professional annihilation.
At the age of 34, I was a successful classical pianist in London, when overnight I stopped being able to perform – in fact I stopped being able to play the piano at all-because of an injury that turned into a chronic pain condition in my arms, neck and back.
I’d played the piano from the age of five. So, it wasn’t simply my career that was in jeopardy. It was my vocation and my entire sense of who I was. I lost all my professional playing work at one stroke: concerts, coaching singers, playing for choirs and opera companies and conservatoires. Gone.
I couldn’t pay my mortgage on my little one-bedroom flat in the suburbs, and I had very little income from some part-time teaching. I lived alone and was in constant pain. It was difficult even to make a meal or wash up. I couldn’t drive or carry shopping.
After the initial shock, confusion and panic, the realization began to dawn: my life as I knew it was over. I can’t pretend that I didn’t “want out” at times. I never seriously considered taking my life, but I certainly spent swathes of time in despair. I couldn’t see a future for myself.
During that dark period, I was fortunate to have the support of family and friends and a wonderful therapist. The main thing I was wrestling with was my identity. I felt a sense of shame, as if it were my fault that I’d become injured and disabled. I had to begin to find a sense of love and acceptance for myself that didn’t depend on my job, my reputation or my accomplishments.
I realised I didn’t really know what remained when those things were taken from me. And this became my new goal: to find a way to love and accept myself unconditionally. On the practical front, I took on more teaching to support myself. And I began to allow myself to dream of other possible futures.
Long story short, five years later, I got on a plane for California to study for a master’s in psychology so I could retrain as a coach for performing and fine artists.
I did this precisely because I wanted to support artists to develop a sense of wholeness and fulfilment that didn’t depend on their latest achievement or failure, their reputation, their résumé or the size of their bank account.
This sense of purpose has fuelled my work as a coach for more than 20 years and brings me as much joy and satisfaction as my previous career, just in a very different way.
Perhaps that’s the question I want to leave you with.
How much are you conflating your work with your sense of who you are? How much of your sense of worth depends on your latest achievement, your reputation, your career or the approval of other people?
And what might remain if all of those things were temporarily taken away?
However catastrophic a professional setback may feel, it doesn’t take away your humanity. It doesn’t take away your capacity to love and be loved. It doesn’t take away the possibility of discovering a different future.
There can be other options. Even when you can’t see them yet.
If you’re having a challenging time at the moment, please don’t assume that the life you’re living now is the only life available to you. And if you need support in finding a way forward, feel free to reach out to me.
And wherever you are now, Jason, I wish you peace.
